PRINCE2 vs. PMBOK - a comparative study


This study is all about the differences and similarities between PRINCE2 and PMBOK (Project Management of Knowledge Guide). PMBOK is more familiar with Americans but not with UK and Europeans, it is likely the opposite is true.

In this article, I would like to focus more on the strengths and weaknesses of both. This would definitely help the reader judge what is appropriate for their needs whether they work as a Project Manager, Project Sponsor, or work in a Project Management Office (PMO).

Project Management today is an evergreen profession, more roles have created globally across many industries. Also, now more organizations are becoming projectised, This is happening as organizations seek to become more efficient – ‘to do more with less’- and to bring new products to market quickly and cheaply.

PMBOK Guide Structure

The PMBOK Guide structures its guidelines into 49 different processes, which are grouped into 5 categories known as Process Groups. A Process Group is a logical grouping of project management inputs, tools and techniques, and output. Each process is described in terms of the inputs required, a set of tools and techniques which can be performed, and the expected outputs.

The same processes are also grouped into Knowledge areas. It defines a Knowledge Area as an “identified area of project management defined by its knowledge requirements and described in terms of its component processes, practices, inputs, outputs, tools, and techniques. It’s actually within the knowledge areas where the details of each process are described. There are 132 tools and techniques referenced in the PMBOK Guide.

PRINCE2 Structure

Mainly, PRINCE2 is having 4 integrated elements: principles, themes, processes, and tailored to suit the needs of the project environment. The 7 principles are the building blocks upon which everything is based. The principles are required to consider a project to be a PRINCE2 Project. There are 7 themes, which are inevitable aspects of project management that must be addressed throughout the lifetime of the project, so themes are applied throughout the seven processes. The processes define the activities to perform through the phases of the project and clarify who is responsible and accountable for what and when. Furthermore, PRINCE2 provides some guidance on how to tailor the method to different projects, depending on the size, risk, and complexity of the project. The Theme and process chapters contain guidance on tailoring in different project situations. The main strength of PRINCE2 is its flexibility to be applied to any project of any size that could incorporate iterative Agile development or the more traditional methods.  PRINCE2 would definitely have a project team structure that describes multiple project management team roles, but PMBOK provides an overview about what project manager role.

Both frameworks are useful, and any project manager would be wise to consider having both in their armoury.  Project managers are like mechanics that have a box of tools at their disposal, and the more tools you have, the better you can face any situation.

We are one of the top PRINCE2 training academies in the UK, and now you can have our best offer so that you can be one of the certified PRINCE2 Project Manager. For more information, visit us on https://qrbmc.com or ring us on +44 1327630 355.